Tensions erupted across Brooklyn this week following the controversial visit of Israeli Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir to the borough. The visit, which took place from April 24 to April 28, sparked widespread protests, counter-demonstrations, and heated debates over U.S.-Israel relations, Palestinian rights, and the broader Middle Eastern geopolitical landscape. While the Israeli government hailed the trip as a symbol of growing cooperation, especially between Israel and Jewish communities in the U.S., it also became a flashpoint for deep divisions in Brooklyn, home to one of the largest Jewish populations outside of Israel.
Ben-Gvir, Israel’s Minister of National Security, is known for his hardline stance on Palestinian issues and his controversial remarks regarding Arab citizens of Israel. His visit to Brooklyn—part of a diplomatic mission aimed at strengthening ties with Jewish communities in the U.S.—was met with fierce opposition from various groups, including Palestinian activists, left-wing progressives, and a number of Jewish organizations that are critical of the Israeli government’s policies.
Protests and Clashes in the Streets
The streets of Brooklyn were the scene of fierce protests as demonstrators from diverse backgrounds rallied in opposition to Ben-Gvir’s presence. Thousands of protesters, many waving Palestinian flags and holding signs that read “Free Palestine” and “End Israeli Apartheid,” gathered near key Jewish community centers and synagogues in Brooklyn. The protests, organized by several advocacy groups, included speeches, chants, and marches aimed at denouncing Ben-Gvir’s controversial policies, particularly his role in the Israeli government’s handling of Palestinian territories.
The demonstrations took a more violent turn when groups of counter-protesters, many of them members of pro-Israel organizations, clashed with anti-Ben-Gvir activists. The confrontations led to scuffles, pushing, and shouting matches, with some reports of physical altercations. Local law enforcement was forced to deploy additional officers to control the unrest, and several arrests were made throughout the week. The violence resulted in heightened security at key locations, including synagogues, Jewish community centers, and schools.
According to the New York City Police Department (NYPD), approximately 30 people were arrested over the course of the protests, primarily for disorderly conduct and engaging in physical altercations. However, tensions continued to simmer, with both sides accusing each other of inciting violence and creating an atmosphere of division.
A Divisive Figure: The Itamar Ben-Gvir Controversy
Ben-Gvir’s visit to Brooklyn was part of a broader effort by Israel’s right-wing government to strengthen its relationship with American Jewish communities. The Israeli government, led by Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, has been working to deepen ties with the U.S. Jewish community, many of whom are staunch supporters of Israel. However, Ben-Gvir, who was appointed as Israel’s Minister of National Security in 2022, remains a polarizing figure due to his extreme nationalist views and incendiary comments about Palestinians and Arabs.
Ben-Gvir is known for his advocacy of policies that many consider to be exclusionary and discriminatory. He has openly supported Israeli settler activities in the West Bank and has called for tough measures against Palestinian militants, including endorsing the expulsion of Arab citizens from Israel. His rhetoric has raised alarm among pro-Palestinian groups, civil rights activists, and some members of the Jewish community who fear his hardline approach undermines efforts toward peace and equality in the region.
“We cannot sit by while a man like Itamar Ben-Gvir, who has made hateful and divisive statements about Palestinians, is welcomed with open arms in our communities,” said Amina al-Hamza, a Palestinian-American activist who participated in the protests. “His visit is an endorsement of policies that perpetuate violence, injustice, and the oppression of Palestinians.”
Jewish Community Divided
While many Jewish organizations in the U.S. welcomed Ben-Gvir’s visit, there was notable division within the community itself. Traditional Jewish institutions, including the Jewish Federation of Greater New York and AIPAC (American Israel Public Affairs Committee), have long supported strong U.S.-Israel relations, and some praised the visit as an opportunity to strengthen Jewish identity and solidarity.
However, progressive Jewish groups, such as J Street and IfNotNow, which advocate for a more balanced approach to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, were outspoken in their opposition to Ben-Gvir’s presence in Brooklyn. These groups argue that his policies and views contradict the core values of justice, equality, and human rights, which they believe should guide the U.S.-Israel relationship.
“The Israeli government under Ben-Gvir has taken an increasingly dangerous turn,” said Miriam Lev, a spokesperson for J Street. “By embracing figures like Ben-Gvir, we are sending a message that we are willing to overlook the human rights of Palestinians, a stance that many American Jews, including myself, cannot support.”
The political and ideological divisions among Jewish organizations have been growing in recent years, especially as Israel’s political landscape shifts further to the right. The debate around Ben-Gvir’s visit has only served to amplify these tensions, with some fearing that it could lead to a broader rift within the Jewish community over Israel’s policies toward Palestinians.
Local Political Leaders Weigh In
Local political leaders in Brooklyn have also weighed in on the visit, with some expressing support for the protests while others defended the Israeli minister’s right to visit and engage with the community. Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, whose district includes parts of Brooklyn, voiced her opposition to Ben-Gvir’s visit, stating that the Israeli minister’s actions in Palestine and his rhetoric toward Arab communities were unacceptable.
“Ben-Gvir’s policies and his stance on Palestinian rights are harmful and need to be challenged. It is important that we stand in solidarity with the Palestinian people, especially in a community as diverse as Brooklyn,” Ocasio-Cortez said in a statement.
On the other hand, Brooklyn Borough President Antonio Reynoso expressed concern about the rise in tensions, urging all sides to engage in respectful dialogue. “Brooklyn is a borough that celebrates diversity and inclusivity, and while we may not always agree, we must ensure that these discussions are productive and peaceful,” Reynoso stated.
An Escalating International Debate
Ben-Gvir’s visit to Brooklyn is a reflection of the broader, ongoing debate surrounding Israel’s policies, particularly in relation to its treatment of Palestinians and the growing divide within the Jewish diaspora. In recent years, Israel’s political landscape has shifted sharply rightward, with a growing influence of nationalist factions, and Ben-Gvir represents one of the most controversial figures within this movement.
The events in Brooklyn also mirror the increasing polarization of U.S. politics on issues related to Israel and Palestine. As American politics continues to shift, these debates are becoming more contentious, with pro-Palestinian groups pushing for more critical discussions about Israeli policies, while pro-Israel groups seek to maintain strong support for the Israeli state.
The protests in Brooklyn are just one chapter in an escalating international debate that continues to shape the future of U.S.-Israel relations. As both sides dig in their heels, the question remains whether this tension will lead to constructive dialogue or a deeper rift that further divides both political and religious communities.
NYC Journals 